Benefits & Comp

Small Business Confidence Hit a Record Low, and Large Employers Kept Adding Retirement Benefits Anyway

Two November surveys show the same split from different angles. Large employers are investing in their people through the uncertainty, and small employers are losing candidates on pay they cannot match.

November 19, 2026 · Benefits & Comp
A woman in a red plaid shirt reviewing printed documents with a pen beside a calculator at a desk in a small office

Key Takeaways

  • Principal's Financial Well-Being Index put small and midsize business sentiment at 5.28 out of 10, a record low, against 7.08 for large businesses, the widest gap since March 2021
  • Large employers were three times more likely than small and midsize businesses to have added retirement benefits in 2026
  • Gusto found 26% of small business owners tried to hire in the past year and struggled to find qualified candidates they could afford, and 64% of them said candidates lacked the required skills
  • Only 18% of small business owners are optimistic about the U.S. economy, down from 29% a year earlier, while 61% remain optimistic about their own business

Economic pressure is supposed to be a leveler. Everyone faces the same inflation, the same borrowing costs and the same uncertain customers. Two surveys released last week say otherwise. Large employers are holding their nerve and building out benefits to keep their people. Small employers are at their gloomiest on record and, in a quarter of cases, cannot find a qualified hire they can afford. For HR leaders at smaller organizations, the gap is no longer just about sentiment. It is showing up in the offer letter.

A Record Low on One Side, a Steady Hand on the Other

The Principal Financial Well-Being Index, released November 11, surveyed 1,000 business owners and decision makers at companies with 2 to 10,000 employees between September 14 and October 4. Overall business sentiment fell 8% from July to 6.02 out of 10, tying April 2025 for the lowest score since the index began in 2021. Inside that average, the two halves moved very differently. Small and midsize businesses, defined as those with 2 to 499 employees, fell to 5.28, an all-time low. Large businesses held almost flat at 7.08. Principal says the gap between the two groups is the widest since March 2021.

"The widening gap in sentiment between small and large businesses tells us economic pressure is not landing evenly," said Amy Friedrich, president of Benefits and Protection at Principal. Leaders are separating their own companies from the economy around them: 52% say their company is growing, but only 16% say the U.S. economy is. Optimism about the next 12 months fell 10 points to 40%.

Despite that mood, employers are not cutting benefits. Across the benefits Principal tested, 63% of employers made no changes in 2026, 8% added or expanded a benefit and only 3% reduced or eliminated one. For 2027, 8% plan to add or expand and 1% plan to cut. The additions are not evenly spread, though. According to 401(k) Specialist's report on the index, large employers were three times more likely than smaller firms to have added retirement benefits in 2026, nearly 15% of large businesses plan to add or expand retirement plan financial advice, and financial wellness programs top the list of benefits large businesses plan to add or expand next year.

Where Small Employers Are Losing Candidates

Gusto's 2026 State of Small Business survey, released November 12, looks at the same pressure from inside firms with fewer than 25 employees. Its 1,731 owners are split in the same way Principal's respondents are. Sixty-one percent are optimistic about their own business, unchanged from last year. Only 18% are optimistic about the U.S. economy, down from 29%, and pessimism rose from 50% to 59%. Fifty-nine percent say changing input prices hurt their business over the past year, and 40% say rising interest rates did. More than half, 52%, raised their own prices in the past 12 months.

The hiring finding is the one HR leaders should sit with. Twenty-six percent of owners tried to hire in the past year and struggled to find qualified candidates they could afford. Of those, 64% said candidates lacked the required skills. Gusto found the smallest businesses more often said they simply could not afford what qualified candidates wanted, while somewhat larger small businesses more often cited scheduling conflicts. Gusto senior economist Nich Tremper warned that small firms "continue to face high borrowing costs, and that may continue into 2027."

Why the Benefits Gap Becomes a Hiring Gap

Put the two surveys side by side and the mechanism is plain. Candidates compare total offers, not base salaries. A larger competitor that adds a retirement benefit, financial advice or a wellness program is raising the value of its offer without touching its salary bands. A small employer whose margins are being squeezed by input prices and borrowing costs is less able to respond on either front, so the gap shows up as a candidate who wanted more than the business could pay.

Health coverage widens it further. KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey found workers at firms with fewer than 200 employees pay $9,687 a year toward family coverage, $2,847 more than workers at larger firms, at a time when the average family premium has reached $28,303. We covered that gap in detail last month. The new data shows larger employers extending their lead, not closing it.

None of this means a small employer can outspend a large one. It does mean small employers need to compete deliberately on the parts of the offer they control, and to know exactly where their total package stands before a candidate does the comparison for them.

For HR leaders at smaller organizations heading into renewal and 2027 hiring plans, a practical response looks like this:

Large employers are reading the same economic forecasts as everyone else and deciding to invest in their people anyway. Small employers cannot match that dollar for dollar, but they can stop competing on base pay alone. In a market where a quarter of small owners cannot afford the hire they need, the package has to do more of the work.

Share

More in Benefits & Comp

All Resources →