McLean & Company's 2026 New Hire and Exit Survey benchmarks show the same promise topping both lists for three straight years. A great hiring experience brings people in, but it cannot keep them if the growth they were sold never arrives.
Key Takeaways
Most organizations sell growth to win candidates. New benchmark data suggests many of them are also losing people over it. McLean & Company's 2026 New Hire and Exit Survey Benchmark Reports, released November 17, find that career opportunities were the leading reason employees applied for a job and accepted an offer, and that limited opportunities for career advancement were the leading job-related reason they later left. The pattern held in every year from 2023 to 2025. The promise that closes the offer is the same promise that, unkept, opens the exit.
"If the reason people join is the same reason people leave, that's a signal worth paying attention to," said Laura Hansen-Kohls, senior vice president of HR diagnostics, advisory and data insights at McLean & Company. For HR leaders heading into 2027 workforce planning, the finding reframes retention as a question of whether the career story told during recruiting survives contact with the actual job.
On the way in, 52.5% of new hires said career opportunities were why they applied, and 48.3% said they were why they accepted the offer. On the way out, 43.4% of departing employees cited limited opportunities for career advancement. McLean's Exit Survey Benchmark Report 2026 draws on exit survey data from 2023 to 2025, a period the firm says was shaped by economic uncertainty, slower hiring, and a sharper focus on retaining and developing existing talent. The firm did not publish sample sizes in its announcement, so the figures are best read as directional benchmarks rather than a census of the workforce.
The exit data adds an important qualifier. Personal factors appeared among the top three reasons for leaving for 53.6% of departing employees, ahead of job factors at 41.5%, compensation at 37.3%, and organizational factors at 37.2%. Not every departure is within HR's reach. But job factors, with career advancement leading them, are the category an employer controls most directly, and they sit above pay. McLean also notes that concerns about organizational direction and future stability became more prominent over the period, which makes a visible path forward inside the company even more valuable.
The new hire benchmark shows how easily organizations can misread their own data. Hiring received the strongest results of any area, with 94.4% positive responses, while performance expectations ranked lowest at 86.3%, still positive but trailing. In other words, recruiting is doing its job. The weaker link is what happens after day one, when people start to learn what will actually be expected of them and whether the growth they were promised is real. "The caution for HR leaders is to avoid treating strong onboarding scores as a retention strategy," Hansen-Kohls said.
"A positive hiring experience can create momentum, but it doesn't prove that employees will continue to see a future." – Laura Hansen-Kohls, SVP, McLean & Company
The youngest workers sharpen the stakes. A November 18 analysis from Indeed Hiring Lab and Glassdoor Economic Research finds Gen Z is the most optimistic generation about getting ahead, with a net score of +54 for expecting more opportunity to advance in five years, against +30 for Millennials, +7 for Gen X, and -8 for Baby Boomers. They are also the most mobile: 67% of employed Gen Z workers are open to a new job and 29% are actively looking, compared with 41% and 10% of Boomers. And they are not getting the development support they want. 58% of non-student Gen Z respondents want a mentor, but only 25% say their employer provides one, a 33-point gap.
That combination is exactly the profile McLean's data warns about: people who joined for growth, expect growth, and have one foot out the door if it does not appear. Gen Z already holds 12% of manager roles, according to the same analysis, so the generation most likely to leave over stalled careers is also becoming the next layer of leadership.
Replacing people who leave over advancement is getting harder. isolved's 2026 HR Leaders Report, based on a survey of 1,005 U.S. HR decision makers, found 59% say their workforce has a skills gap, up from 48% in 2025, and 51% describe the situation as a talent crisis. Sixty percent say their recruiting strategies fall short on speed. When the external market cannot deliver skills quickly, the employee who left because no one showed them a next step is a capability loss as well as a turnover statistic.
McLean's own recommendation is to strengthen career development, internal mobility, manager support, and transparent communication, and to use benchmarks as context for an organization's own results rather than as a basis for decisions on their own. The practical work is to connect the recruiting pitch to what employees actually experience in their first two years.
Recruiting has done its part: people are arriving because they believe they can build a career. Whether they stay depends on whether that belief survives the first performance review, the first reorganization, and the first year without a visible next step. McLean's data says that for a large share of departing employees, it did not. The cheapest retention lever available to HR may simply be making the promise from the job posting true.
Guide
When career opportunity is both the top reason people accept an offer and a leading reason they leave, this guide helps HR line up what wins candidates with what keeps them once they join.
Download
Guide
Spotting that the same growth promise drives both acceptances and exits takes new hire, turnover, and internal mobility metrics read together, and this guide explains how to track and act on each.
Download
Guide
With 43.4% of leavers citing limited advancement and a 33-point Gen Z mentoring gap, this guide surfaces the development dimensions HR most often misses when building the career paths employees were promised.
Download
Oyster's 2026 Global AI Talent Report found most companies that changed existing roles left title and pay untouched.
Flattening handed surviving managers 12.1 direct reports and 22% engagement. Gallup's newest data says team size isn't what's breaking them.
Organizations investing in targeted reskilling programs are seeing stronger internal mobility and lower attrition.